9 reasons why the highline sucks

The Highline is fashionable in every sense. A park inspired by one in Paris, a combination of Euro chic, treehugging sanctity and hipster industrial grunge.

But it sits above ground, shovels people off the streets via stairs which cyclists can’t use and leads from nowhere to nowhere. In addition, little money has been spend on the dark spaces underneath, which could easily negate any benefit provided above.

The designers involved are great and there are nice touches, but could it have been better just to have torn it down and created something at street level. Such talk is heresy, but here are 9 reasons why we are disbelievers.


(Ranked by user votes) Vote on and review the contenders below.
 
Most things look great when they first open, and its hard to imagine that the Highline could become a needle park, but there is a danger it could.<p /><p />Urban parks are always a trade off between making spaces open enough that they are naturally overlooked rather than security patrolled and closed enough that they create intimate spaces.<p /><p />Intimate spaces created by planting are hugely desirable in a city, but by being above ground, away from street life, the latitude to add extra intimacy is reduced by the fact that it will already be difficult to keep it from being scary at night.
Models and drawings with long shallow curves, like this one, look modern. Its more difficult to make a traditional, symmetric, square or oval park look good but these spaces usually work better as tranquil parks, precisely because they are less dynamic.<p /><p />The Highline has the natural shallow curves of a railroad. Before the days of computer models, Zaha Hadid, the designer of the project above, was famous for her set of railway curves which she used to draw seductive shallow curved presentation drawings.
Linear parks are often a great way to link parks or green areas together. This image says it all. The Highline is a bridge to nowhere.
When you create a park above street level you have to be careful that the negative aspects of the space underneath it dont cancel out the benefits above.<p /><p />There is often an initial phase where spaces underneath look good, but after a while these places tend to become depressing or fall into disrepair.<p /><p />The Highline should have been as much about the space beneath as it was about the park itself. For obvious reasons the focus has been on the park.
Complete separation of traffic from urban areas sometimes makes places dead and being long and thin, linear parks really work when they can be used as a route from A to B. Mixing cycle traffic with linear parks is a good idea for everyone, but the Highline doesnt work as a place to cut through with stairs rather than ramps.
The conversion of an old steel works into a park, in Duisburg, Germany creates dramatic use of the space using lighting. The highline seems to ignore the dramatic possibilities here.
Of course landscape is much more than planting, but as this image suggests little has been done to landscape this area than clean up the building and leave a few estranged looking cafe chairs strewn about.
It takes a long time for planting in parks to mature. At the moment the Highline looks more like nascent greenery sprouting through cracks in the pavement.<p /><p />What works for the moment, is the Highline&#039;s novelty, as it becomes a mature park, the spaces underneath will require lots of money flowing into them to prevent them from being dank railway arches.<p /><p />There doesn&#039;t seem to be a 30 year plan for what is underneath the Highline.
Like the Highline, the Barbican Center in London created a pedestrianized zone one level above the street. It has become a sad and lonely place and people still use the street level underpass which is hostile to pedestrians.

More lists...

10 abandoned subway stations | 10 anti-masturbation devices | 10 antique phonographs | 10 best power strip designs | 10 classic jacob jensen gadgets | 10 classic reel-to-reel recorders | 10 classic tim burton movies | 10 console light guns | 10 dry land submarines | 10 enormous floating cranes | 10 failed automobile manufacturers | 10 flea circus contraptions | 10 gas guzzlers | 10 incredibly tacky cars | 10 james dyson inventions | 10 luxury trains | 10 massive steam hammers | 10 money making machines | 10 mud huts yurts tents and an igloo with satellite | 10 neat camera hacks | 10 notable olympic flame cauldron designs | 10 obsolete web browsers | 10 reasons not to switch | 10 rocket launch pads | 10 ski jumps | 10 strange snow vehicles | 10 transparent watches | 10 unboring ferris wheels | 10 unoperational operating theaters | 10 videos of ejection seat tests | 10 voting machines | 12 advertainment video games | 12 awful GUIs | 12 banned music videos | 12 batman vehicles | 12 box guitars | 12 cardboard creations | 12 centrifuge gforce test videos | 12 Classic Raymond Loewy Designs | 12 classic sony designs | 12 claustrophobic space capsules | 12 claustrophobic torpedo rooms | 12 clay car mockups | 12 concealed guns | 12 countries 12 condom commercials (videos) | 12 different food rations | 12 disposable gadgets | 12 DIY bicycles | 12 dry land swimming machines | 12 ejector seats | 12 elegantly deconstructed machines | 12 enormous propellers | 12 failed apple products | 12 failed gaming consoles | 12 famous daredevils | 12 great modern fountains | 12 haptic interfaces | 12 hazmat suits | 12 health lies cigarette ads | 12 hyperbaric chambers | 12 inhabited bridges | 12 insane highways | 12 Knife Bikes | 12 luxury airlines | 12 Magic Lanterns | 12 Mars Mission Failures | 12 mesmerizing kinetic sculptures (videos) | 12 movie industry camera cars | 12 moving building facades (videos) | 12 object covered cars | 12 of the worlds most fascinating tunnel networks | 12 pink tanks | 12 pleasure piers | 12 Pocket Sundials | 12 primitive b movie style robots | 12 real life cutaway cars | 12 real life glove boxes | 12 real life jenga buildings | 12 rockin guitar hero mods | 12 seized weapons caches | 12 sexist vintage ads | 12 ships with impossibly large cargo | 12 smoke hoods | 12 Space Rocket Launch Videos | 12 spectacular erections | 12 steampunk stirling engines (videos) | 12 stunning card creations | 12 stunning rooftop gardens | 12 tiny Indian school buses | 12 Types of Crash Test Dummy | 12 ultra complex surface analysis systems | 12 very disturbing paintball teams | 12 videos of ships being launched | 12 videos of spiderman climbing real skyscrapers | 12 videos of welding machines | 12 vintage printing presses | 12 vintage walkmans | 12 wild west ghost towns | 12 worst iPhone case designs | 13 disgusting pepsi flavors | 14 cameras that look just like guns | 15 abandoned theaters | 15 architects 15 chairs | 15 Blade Runner Buildings | 15 Founding Father Invention Myths | 15 giant transporters | 15 high speed trains | 15 housing projects from hell | 15 images of not so secret secret service buildings | 15 knockoff gadgets | 15 monstrous harvesters | 15 odd pods | 15 of the worst american foods | 15 payphones from around the world | 15 pneumatic message networks | 15 radical beach buggies | 15 scifi movies 15 famous architectural locations | 15 skyscrapers on hold | 15 Solar Cookers | 15 spectacular eye testing gadgets | 15 splendid sidecars | 15 videos of amazing rolling ball machines | 15 wall climbing robots | 16 bat houses and bat caves | 16 concept watches | 16 Genuine Cyborg Technologies | 16 giant bucket excavators | 16 hilariously unimpressive computer ads | 16 impressive examples of bamboo scaffolding | 16 thanksgiving turkey fryer videos | 17 architectural light sculptures | 17 found object chandeliers | 18 hovercraft designs | 18 really tiny projectors | 20 cipher devices | 20 classic 8mm movie cameras | 20 interesting boring machines | 20 railroad snowplows | 20 unusual tractor designs | 2007 countdown clocks | 3d printed products | 8 Classic Nakamichi Cassette Decks | 8 extreme truck load videos | 8 inflatable military decoys | 8 inflatable shelters | 8 moving houses videos | 8 pointless uses of carbon fiber | 8 Sky Hooks | 9 reasons why the highline sucks | a dozen vintage spy radios | a visual history of video recorders | abandoned pools | abandoned space technology | abandoned technology | aerial refueling | aircraft factories | algorithmic architecture | all time worst apple products | amazing analog computers | amazing atomic clocks | anechoic chamber architecture | anniversary edition products | apple II commercials (videos) | Apple monocoque or not | arab drifts (videos) | arabian mega skyscrapers | armor for animals | bad design gull wing cars | bang and olufsen creations | bank vaults | beautiful lighthouse lights | beautiful wind turbines | best apple concept mockups | best concept cellphones | best concept laptops | best gadgets at ceatec 2007 | best halloweenerd costumes | best interactive clothes | Best iPod Speakers | best keyboards | best lego stop motion videos | best lighting designs | best of ebay oobjects jan 25 08 | best of oobject jan 09 | best pet poop gadgets | best remote controlled gadgets | best Rube Goldberg Machine videos | best steve jobs speech ever (videos) | best time machines | best travel gadgets | big fun alarm clocks | biggest apple design ripoffs | biggest gimmick bottle openers | biggest tech product failures | bizarre drawing contraption videos | bizarre pedal powered things | black rat bikes | blatant ipod iphoneys | boombox bikes | brick sized cellphone ads (videos) | bubble cars | buildings in converted silos | buildings in old planes | bus stops as architecture | bus stops as art | carbon fiber creations | cardboard robot costumes | cars from classic 80s movies | cars in space | ces video roundup | chinese factories | Chip Burka People | classic car user interfaces | classic gerry anderson scifi toys | classic microphones | classic pininfarina designs | collapsible gadgets | concept folding bikes | control rooms of all types | cool aircraft interiors | cool pocket sized gadgets | coolest vintage phones | craftsy weapons | crazy about tetris | crazy bicycles | crazy floating buildings | crazy japanese watches | crazy tesla coils | daredevil walls of death | dazzle ships | definitive list of subway architecture | dental chairs through history | different types of galvanometer | diving helmets | diy frankenstein lab items | drug smuggling submarines | earliest wrist watches | election broadcast technology through history | every postwar olympic stadium | examples of instant architecture | exoskeletons | extraordinary armor | extreme kitchen gadgets | extreme vietnamese street cabling | famous les paul guitars | fantastic vintage tvs | ferocious oil drill bits | flash flashlights | flying helmets | flying machines | flying saucers | formula 1 user interfaces | futuristic biometric devices | futuristic cellular structure architecture | futuristic german car factories (videos) | futuristic interfaces | futuristic megastructures | futuristic ross lovegrove design | geek hall of fame apple users | geeky papercraft | general store architecture | ghost particle detectors | giant airship hangars | giant cranes | giant molten steel handling equipment | giant screens | graffiti covered | great climbing walls | great diy lighting ideas | gun shaped non guns | handmade super mario bros | homage to the chrysler | homage to the light bulb | IKEA in Hell | impressive moving bridges | inappropriate rocket powered items | incredible listening devices | incredible planetarium projectors | incredibly embarrassing lip dubs | industrial crushing machines | innovative lights | interesting balloons | interesting false teeth | interesting soapbox derby racers | ironic gun advertising | items to build an apple store | jet engine test videos | jumping off notable architecture (and surviving) videos | laptop stands | lego like modular gadgets | life with a gas mask | light pipe architecture | linotypes from hell | lots of yellow submarines | macys parade ideas | massive record collections | mathematical lighting | mechanical animals | mechanical marvel calculators | mechanical planetary models | medical manikins | memento mori timepieces | mind reading devices | miscellany october 08 | mobile media devices | monster 80s boomboxes | most beautiful airport terminals | most beautiful land speed record vehicles | most beautiful spiral staircases | most blatant ipod copies | most complex watches | most extreme clothes | most extreme speakers | most extreme turntables | most wonderful telescopes | Movies of moving picture machines (videos) | moving walkways of note | musical instrument mashups | naked gadgets | nerds on segways | non Apple minimalist gadgets | nuclear powered transportation | odd spy cams | oil boom diamond kitsch | oil crisis car ads | only laptops to buy | Oobjects perfect gadget bag | Peoples choice CES 2008 day 1 | peoples choice gadget of 2007 | physical cutaway models | pictures of the lego house construction progress | pissoir designs | planetariums around the world | post modern cuckoo clocks | radar consoles | radioactive products | real gotham city | really cool pools | resqtec emergency devices | retro saturday morning cartoons | revolting gold gadgets | Rocket Sleds | sci-fi costume fails | sextants | Shanghai vs Beijing architectural bakeoff | ships out of water | sinister bbc spy vehicles | Sky Captain gadgets & vehicles | snowmobiles through history | soviet satellites | spaceship like hot tubs | spectacular sewers | spectacular wind tunnels | star wars fanatics | start up sequences | stereo cameras | Steve Jobs vs America since 97 (videos) | strange musical instruments | stunning ray guns | stunning streamlined trailers | submarine construction and decommissioning | super sewer robots | surreal underwater technology | survival kits | sword and gadget canes | tattoo machines | terrifying mining gear | The 10 most important examples of neon signage | the architect of detroit | the best designed toolboxes | the best of the hubble telescope | the escapades of steve ballmer | the genealogy of fixies | the golden age of american concept cars | The Great SMS Swindle | The Life of the Nintendo 64 | the perfect laptop stand | the pigeon net | the wildest sports fans | time lapse wii videos | tiniest gadgets | top 10 interesting tool chests | Top 10 Moon Rocket Models | top 10 oddball foosball tables | Top 10 Soviet Technology Ripoffs | top 10 unusual burglar alarms | top 12 harley earl designs | top 12 videos of creepy automata | top 15 classic calculator watches | Top 15 modernist gas stations | top circuit bent kids toys (videos) | top supercomputers | toy robot commercials through history (videos) | trading places | transparent glass stairs | tricked out gadget suitcases | tube testers | typology of milk floats | ultimate headphones | ultra zoom cameras | unreadable minimalist watches | unusual gas masks | unusual rubber duckies | unusual suitcase kits | video list of 3D printers in action | videos of self assembling machines | Vintage Analog Lie Detectors | vintage analog synthesizers | vintage erector sets to buy | vintage fans for sale | Vintage Massage Gadgets | watches worn in space | weird lights | weird outlaw radio transmitters | wonderful altoids hacks | wonderful tensegrity structures | wonderful welding masks | world changing gadgets | worlds greatest elevator rides (videos) | worst general lee | worst keytar (videos) | zoobject cryptozoology quiz |